As a landlord, screening tenants is one of the most important parts of protecting your investment. A solid tenant screening process helps ensure that you’re choosing responsible renters who will respect your property, pay on time, and uphold the lease agreement. But there’s a fine line between gathering important information and asking illegal or discriminatory questions.
At Tenant Screening Center Inc., we help landlords across the country conduct professional tenant verification and background checks that are thorough, compliant, and fair. One of the most common pitfalls we see is landlords unintentionally asking prohibited questions during the rental application process. These missteps can lead to legal trouble, financial penalties, and discrimination claims.
Here’s what you need to know about what you can’t ask prospective tenants—and how to screen responsibly.
Why It Matters
Federal fair housing laws, primarily enforced by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), prohibit housing discrimination based on:
- Race
- Color
- National origin
- Religion
- Sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation)
- Familial status
- Disability
In addition, many states and municipalities have their own fair housing laws that go even further. Violations—even if accidental—can lead to lawsuits, fines, and damage to your reputation.
Questions You Should Avoid Asking
1. Do you have children?
This question falls under “familial status” and is protected under the Fair Housing Act. You cannot ask if a tenant has children, how many children they have, or whether they’re planning to have children. While you may need to ask how many occupants will live in the unit for safety or space compliance, it must be framed in a neutral, non-discriminatory way.
2. What is your race, ethnicity, or nationality?
Questions related to race or national origin are strictly off-limits. Never ask where a person is from or their native language. Even asking about accent or country of origin can appear discriminatory, even if unintended.
3. Are you married, single, or divorced?
Questions about marital status can imply a preference and fall into discriminatory territory. Stick to facts that relate to the lease and occupancy, not personal life details.
4. What is your religion or where do you worship?
This is another protected class under federal law. Even casual questions like “Do you go to church around here?” could be problematic.
5. Are you disabled? Or: How severe is your disability?
It is illegal to ask questions that reveal a tenant’s disability. You can’t ask about physical or mental health conditions, nor can you ask how they plan to live independently. If someone requests a reasonable accommodation (like a service animal), you can ask for documentation from a medical professional, but you should never pry.
6. What’s your sexual orientation or gender identity?
This is increasingly becoming a protected class in many jurisdictions and is off-limits during screening.
7. Have you ever been arrested?
Note the key word here: arrested, not convicted. You may inquire about prior convictions if they’re directly relevant to tenant safety or property condition, but blanket bans on criminal records have come under scrutiny by HUD. A case-by-case assessment is safer and fairer.
8. Do you plan to retire soon? / How old are you?
Age is a protected class under several state laws, and questions about age or retirement status can be interpreted as discriminatory.
What You Can Ask
While the list above may feel restrictive, landlords are still allowed—and encouraged—to collect important, relevant information. Here are a few examples of acceptable questions:
- What is your monthly income?
- Can you provide landlord references?
- Do you consent to a tenant background check?
- Are you willing to sign a 12-month lease?
- Do you have any pets?
- How many people will live in the unit?
- Can you provide proof of employment?
These questions focus on financial responsibility and lease adherence—exactly what a good tenant screening process is designed to assess.
Tips to Stay Compliant
- Use a Standardized Application
Ensure you’re using a professional, legally vetted rental application for every prospective tenant. Avoid verbal-only screening that can lead to inconsistent treatment. - Be Consistent
Treat every applicant the same. Apply the same screening criteria, same background check process, and same questions for all applicants. - Document Everything
Keep records of communications, forms, approvals, and denials. This protects you in the event of a dispute or legal review. - Use a Professional Screening Service
Working with a trusted tenant screening company like Tenant Screening Center Inc. ensures that your process follows all federal, state, and local laws. We offer comprehensive tenant background checks, credit reports, and verification tools to help you make the best rental decisions—safely and legally.
Final Reminder: Verify Before You Trust
It’s important to remember: Tenant Screening and Tenant Background Checks help identify tenants who will be fair to you. The key is to stay informed, be consistent, and never guess when it comes to the law.
✅ We’re here to help you rent responsibly
✅ We stay current on legal requirements
✅ We make compliance easy
⚠️ Note: Laws vary depending on your jurisdiction and are subject to change. Always consult a qualified attorney or a recognized tenant screening service when reviewing or updating your process.
Looking for a fair, legal, and effective tenant screening process?
Visit Tenant Screening Center Inc. and start protecting your rental investment the right way.
Landlords Property Managers Contact TSCI